Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Azark's avatar

I agree completely with this article - we are trapped by the clocks. The only thing I'd like to ask... Perhaps a more tricky question is how do we actually free ourselves and not care about time when it's so tied to everything else?

I go to school for 8 hours a day, and quite literally law forces me to move from period to period even if I get in a creative flow in 1st period and want to keep creating art, I need to leave else I be marked absent.

Also, time is actually important if we want to organize events where a lot of people are meeting at once. It's a different world here in the US - people live in different places, and meetings must usually be planned. We can't just forget about time and stop by at all our friends' houses, spontaneously asking if they want to go for dinner. I wish we could, but we can't.

So what forms of resistance can we transition to? Maybe taking off our watches or hiding the time on our phones and laptops. When we get home after our 8 hours under the time tyrant maybe we just let ourselves forget about it. Cut our losses and sieze what we can. What do you think?

Expand full comment
Kkc's avatar
Jul 17Edited

This article puts into perceptive scientists’ reluctance to accept that bees have an endogenous clock.

In the early 20th century, a scientist put sugar water outside of a bee's hive every day at 4pm. Soon enough, the bees learned to leave the hive every day at 4pm, even when there was no sugar water, suggesting bees can measure and perceive time.

This conclusion was met with criticism as skeptics argued that the bees weren't perceiving time, and were measuring the angle of the sun. So they re-did the experiment in the dark, and still the bees came out at 4pm. Even then, skeptics weren't satisfied, and suggested the bees were measuring the heat of the sun instead.

And so scientists recreated the experiment underground in a salt mine. When the bees once again came out at 4pm, many argued that the bees were measuring the rotation of the Earth instead (which is a far more advanced and impressive ability???)

Later on, a scientist conducted the experiment in Paris, and then flew the bees to New York City, where they left the hive at 10 in the morning, because they experienced jet lag, finally settling the debate that bees can perceive time.

As humans ruled by clocks, we resist the idea that bees can tell time because this reveals their disregard for our tyrant altogether. We cling to the belief that intelligence is ours alone, and that our inventions chart a noble ascent toward some pinnacle of existence. Because if bees don’t need our gods, then we are forced to question who our gods are and if we were ever gods. This also challenges our innovative trajectory and our place “above nature”.

Expand full comment
2 more comments...

No posts